The Black Tapes S2 I enjoyed though I do admit to preferring their other show Tanis a lot more. I also love Ars Paradoxica and The Bright Sessions a whole lot. Kings Fall AM is also pretty fun.

I still listen to Night Vale and then there's also their other show, Alice Isn't Dead, which was pretty awesome.

I also love Saga and Myths and Legends for some of the better mythology/folklore podcasts.